Graco Premium Crib & Toddler Mattress – GREENGUARD Gold Certified & Cert...

  Must Have

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "Mattress only"

LOVEVERY | The Play Gym | Award Winning For Baby , Stage-Based Developme...

  Must Have

Hatch Rest Go | Portable Sound Machine for Babies and Kids | Sleep Sooth...

  Must Have

Ali+Oli Silicone Pacifier Clip for Baby (Taupe Wood) 100% Food-Grade BPA...

  Must Have

Philips Avent Natural Response Nipples, Fast Flow (Flow 4), 4-Pack, SCY9...

  Must Have

Tommee Tippee Multiwarm Bottle and Pouch Warmer, White, Warms Baby Feeds...

  Must Have

Blissful Diary Muslin Baby Changing Pad with Waterproof Lining Foam, Dia...

  Must Have

XMWEALTHY Cute Baby Items Newborn Plush Nursery Swaddle Blankets Soft In...

  Must Have

Konssy Baby Girl Newborn Receiving Blanket with Headband Set Baby Swaddl...

  Must Have

Nuna DEMI Next Bassinet & Stand

  Must Have

Cute Castle 12 Pack Muslin Burp Cloths for Baby - Ultra-Soft 100% Cotton...

  Must Have

Burt's Bees Baby Shampoo & Wash, Tear Free Soap, Baby Care, Original,12 ...

HEMNES 8-drawer dresser, white stain, 63x373/4" - IKEA

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "Looking for any sort of dresser. This one is great for having half of the side for the changing table and half the side for anything else. It's actual wood not particle board. It has rollers in the drawers."

ARENTI Split-Screen Baby Monitor 2 Cameras, Audio Monitor with Two 2K UH...

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "Includes a physical baby monitor & you can use your phone. Comes with 2 cameras. You can temporarily give people access to the monitor on their phone. and has 2 way talking."

Fixwal Nursery Book Shelves, 23.6 Inch Floating Bookshelves for Wall Set...

lulumoon Baby Muslin Bassinet Sheets: Cotton Bassinet Sheets Neutral for...

Ubbi Baby Wipes Dispenser | Baby Wipes Case | Baby Wipes Holder with Wei...

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "Carlyn added this one"

Lifewit 5 Pack Drawer Dividers 5" High, 13.5-22" Adjustable Clothes Orga...

Itzy Ritzy Pacifier Holder Case with Clip - Pacifier Case Includes Clasp...

Nutmeg Compact Stroller – Lightweight and Compact Stroller with One-Hand...

Itzy Ritzy Adjustable Stroller Caddy/Organizer - Stroller Organizer Bag ...

Ninni Pacifier Oatmeal 2 Pack

Natursutten Pacifiers 0-6 Months - 1-Pack Butterfly Shield Round Nipple ...

2 Pack Wet Dry Bags for Baby Cloth Diapers&Breast Pump Parts, Waterproof...

Alpine Muffy Baby Comfort - Protects Hearing for Babies and Toddlers - C...

Unisex Short-Sleeve Bodysuit for Baby

Gerber baby-girls Boys and Girls 12 Piece Layette Gift Set

Philips Avent Natural Glass Baby Bottles with Natural Response Nipples (...

Mockingbird High Chair

Baby Einstein Around We Grow 4-in-1 Walker, Discovery Activity Center an...

Nature’s Way Sambucus Elderberry Traditional Immune Syrup, Highly Concen...

Medi Frida the Accu-Dose Pacifier Baby Medicine Dispenser by FridaBaby

Simple Joys by Carter's Unisex Babies' 8-Piece Towel and Washcloth Set, ...

Kindred Bravely Organic Reusable Nursing Pads, Washable, for Breastfeedi...

WeeSprout Suction Plates with Lids for Babies & Toddlers - 100% Silicone...

Kindred Bravely Organic Reusable Nursing Pads, Washable, for Breastfeedi...

Lansinoh Breast Therapy Packs, Hot and Cold Breast-Pads with 2 Soft Cove...

Koala Babycare The Original Nursing Cups 100% Silver – Nipple Shields fo...

PandaEar Set of 3 Silicone Baby Bibs Waterproof, Soft, Unisex, 10-72 Mon...

Porcelain Divided Plates with Silicone Sleeves | Suitable for Babies/Kid...

Smallshow Women's Maternity Nursing Tops Short Sleeve Breastfeeding Clothes

Konjac Body Sponge (2 Pack) Exfoliating Crushed Walnut | 100% Natural & ...

Frida Baby NoseFrida SnotSucker for Baby, Nasal Aspirator for Baby, Nose...

haakaa Baby Nail File Electric Baby Nail Care Set with LED Light, Baby N...

Matys Baby Chest Rub, Soothing Congestion Relief Vapor Rub for Babies 3 ...

Natemia Soft Bristle Baby Hair Brush - Wooden Toddler & Newborn Grooming...

Triple Paste Diaper Rash Cream for Baby - 3 oz Tube - Zinc Oxide Ointmen...

Desitin Maximum Strength Baby Diaper Rash Cream, 40% Zinc Oxide for Trea...

Little Remedies Gripe Water-No Alcohol, Sodium Bicarbonate, Artificial C...

Herb Pharm Kids Mullein and Garlic Oil, Calendula, Garlic, Mullein, St. ...

Babyletto Kiwi Navy Blue Electronic Swivel Glider Power Recliner Nursery...

  Must Have

Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed - Ultra-Breathable Proven to R...

  Must Have

Burt's Bees Baby Essential Organic Cotton Fitted Crib Sheet, Breathable ...

  Must Have

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "x3 to do the mattress pad/sheet sandwich"

Naturepedic Organic Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad, Skin Friendly, Breatha...

  Must Have

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "x3 to do the mattress pad/sheet sandwich"

The Wave Crib | Convertible Crib To Toddler Bed | Nestig

  Must Have

Keekaroo Peanut Changer Baby Vanilla– The Original Made in USA Easy-to-C...

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "Has a nice slight angle so pee doesn't stream back into baby's shirt."

Mr. Pen- Baby Diaper Caddy Organizer, Beige, Baby Organizer, Car Diaper ...

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "like an indoor diaper bag bringing things from room to room. Super nice for taking things around."

Set of 12 Drawer Organizer, Fabric Closet Organizer and Storage Baskets,...

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "Put in dresser."

JolyWell Baby Night Light for Kid, Portable Egg Nightlight with Stable C...

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "for nighttime diaper changes so baby doesn't wake up. non stimulating low light."

Diaper Genie Platinum Pail (Lilly White) is Made of Durable Stainless St...

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "NEED special bags. this is the easiest to switch out new bags of the genie brands."

Hatch Rest+ Baby & Kids Sound Machine | 2nd Gen | Child’s Night Light, A...

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "Specifically the + 2nd Gen so you can move it around. is nice because it can be battery powered so it can be carried around."

TinyBums Baby Wipe Warmer & Dispenser with LED Changing Light & On/Off S...

BabyBjörn Bouncer Bliss, Sand Gray, Woven, Classic Quilt | 2-in-1 Adjust...

Babyletto Scoot 3-Drawer Changer Dresser with Removable Changing Tray in...

Itzy Ritzy Diaper Bag Backpack – Large Capacity Boss Plus Baby Backpack ...

  Must Have

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "you can buy used on amazon."

The Honest Company Clean Conscious Multi-Use Wipes | Hypoallergenic + Un...

  Must Have

Kirkland Signature Diapers Size 1 (Up to 14 Pounds) 192 Count W/Exclusiv...

  Must Have

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "Feel free to share other diaper company recommendations if you'd like."

Kirkland Signature Diapers, Size 2 (174-Count)

  Must Have

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "apparently we need about 400 of these."

Cloth Diaper Waterproof Covers - Esembly Baby

  Must Have

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "we like the colors: sbm botanic garden, wwf bluebberries,"

Reusable Cloth Baby Wipes - Esembly Baby

  Must Have

Bumco Baby Bum Brush + Mini Baby Diaper Cream Spatula with Case - BPA-Fr...

  Must Have

Esembly Cloth Diaper Inner, Size 1 (7-17lbs) Trim-Fitting, Certified Org...

  Must Have

Pampers Baby Diapers - Swaddlers - Size 0, 140 Count, Ultra Absorbent Di...

  Must Have

ALVABABY 2 Pack Reusable Diaper Pail Liner for Cloth Diaper,Rubbish Bag,...

  Must Have

Esembly Cloth Diaper Inner, Size 2, Trim-Fitting, Certified Organic Cott...

  Must Have

Mr. Pen- Baby Diaper Caddy Organizer with Lid, Baby Organizer, Diaper Ca...

OsoCozy Unbleached Flannel Cloth Baby Wipes - Reusable & Washable Saves ...

Balmex Complete Protection Daily Baby Diaper Rash Cream, Clinically Prov...

Angelcare Baby Bath Support (Gray) | Ideal for Babies Less Than 6 Months...

Yookidoo Baby Tummy Time Mat Newborn Musical Playmat & Outdoor Gym. Pill...

Melissa & Doug Safari Buddies Hand Puppets, Set of 6 (Elephant, Tiger, P...

Fat Brain Toys InnyBin Shape Learning Toys, Sensory Toys for Babies and ...

Sassy Play My Way Infant Gift Set - 6 Pieces - Ages 0+ Months

Bright Starts Easy-Grasp Oball Bundle Gift Set - Grasp The Day, Ball and...

Tummy Time Baby Mirror Infant Toys Newborn 0 3 Months Brain Development ...

Living Textiles Baby Musical Mobile - Ava Birds | Crib Toy, Knitted Wood...

Cleaning Brush,Soft Kitchen Scrub Brush,Reusable Silicone Bottle Cleanin...

OXO Tot Space Saving Drying Rack + Dishwasher Basket for Kitchen

Haakaa Manual Breast Pump Silicone Breast Pump Milk Saver Milk Pump with...

My Brest Friend Nursing Pillow - Deluxe - Enhanced Comfort w/Slipcover -...

  Must Have

eufy Heated Wearable Breast Pump S1 Pro, Slim Hands-Free Breast Pump wit...

  Must Have

Baby Bottle Handles for Philips Avent Natural Baby Bottles, Compatible A...

  Must Have

Baby Brezza New and Improved Formula Pro Advanced Formula Dispenser Mach...

  Must Have

Momcozy KleanPal Pro Baby Bottle Washer, Sterilizer & Dryer - All-in-One...

  Must Have

We Are Amma The Cocoon - Natural, Small / Medium | Babylist Shop

Breast Milk Freezer Storage Trays w/Carrier, 10-1oz Bars, 2 Silicone Con...

Comotomo Baby Bottle Bundle, Green, (7 Piece Set)

Simple Houseware Stackable 2 Tier Basket Drawer, White

Jam Naturals- Cute Bear Baby Swaddle Wraps - Soft & Lightweight Swaddle ...

  Must Have

Baby Closet Dividers for Clothes Organizer - Set of 7 Adorable Wooden Do...

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "helpful for all the hanging clothes so you're not wondering what size everything is."

Pink Swaddle Sleep Sack

Halo Sleep Swaddle 100% Cotton

Gerber Baby Girls' 6-Pair Sock

Note from Amy & Gabriel: "Best rated for not falling off."

Konssy Muslin Baby Bibs 10 Pack Baby Bandana Drool Bibs 100% Cotton for ...

Jam Naturals- Organic Knotted Tie Bottom Adjustable Velcro Swaddle and H...

efluky Slim Laundry Basket with Lid, Narrow Laundry Hamper with Removabl...

ZIRI & ZANE Baby Sock Gift Set - 7 Unique Pairs, Cute & Funny Unisex New...