Baby Swaddle - Limoncello Calla Lily

$28.00

mushie Muslin Baby Swaddle Blanket | 100% Organic Cotton (Blue Flowers)

$19.99

mushie Muslin Baby Swaddle Blanket | 100% Organic Cotton (Bows)

$19.99

mushie Muslin Baby Cloths | 100% Organic Cotton | 23.5" x 23.5" (Fog) 3-...

$22.99

mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet | 192 Thread Count | 28"x 52"...

$29.99

mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted MINI Crib Sheet | 24"x 38" (Natural Stripe)

$26.99

Inglesina Welcome Pod Baby Lounger (0–8 Months) – US Compliant Infant Lo...

$99.00

mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted MINI Crib Sheet | 24"x 38" (Sun)

$26.99

mushie Muslin Baby Swaddle Blanket | 100% Organic Cotton (Pastel Blooms)

$19.99

mushie Muslin Baby Swaddle Blanket | 100% Organic Cotton (Happy Flowers ...

$19.99

mushie Muslin Baby Swaddle Blanket | 100% Organic Cotton (Flowers)

$19.99

Harbor Baby Monitor

  Must Have

RAVA™ Flame Retardant–Free Convertible Car Seat

Taylie Backpack - Peachy Puakenikeni

$115.00

Baby Swing Cover - Compatible with 4moms MamaRoo 4 Old Model Before 2022...

$38.99

Universal Silicone Stroller Organizer | Waterproof, Easy-Clean Caddy wit...

$42.99

Gaiatop Mini Electric Fan with 360 Rotation, 5.5mm Gaps, Rechargeable Ba...

$19.99

Mobile Connector Replacement, Toy Pole Conversion Attachment for 4moms M...

$9.99

4moms RockaRoo and MamaRoo Infant Insert, Machine Washable, Cool Mesh Fa...

$39.99

OTTOCAST Cabin Care Baby Camera for Car, 1080P Baby Car Camera with HD N...

$124.99

Millie Moon Luxury Disposable Diapers - Size 3 - 144ct

$39.99

  Must Have

Ballet Slippers Diaper Covers

$59.95

Organic Cotton Doublers 3-pack

$9.55

  Must Have

Earth Mama Organic Diaper Balm 2-Ounce | Diaper Cream for Baby | EWG Ver...

$27.98

Millie Moon 99% Pure Water Baby Wipes - 576ct

$28.49

Stay Dry Natural Duo Insert

$9.65

  Must Have

Millie Moon Luxury Disposable Diapers - Size 1 - 32ct

$8.99

  Must Have

Duo Wrap (Hook and Loop)

$15.40

  Must Have

Note from Keani & Michael: "$5 for shipping to Hawaii. To get free shipping you can add another product from Thirsties."

EveryLife Wipes

$22.99

Duo Wrap (Snap)

$15.40

  Must Have

Note from Keani & Michael: "$5 for shipping to Hawaii. To get free shipping you can add another product from Thirsties."

Diaper Liners for Cloth Diapers, 100 Disposable Sheets Per Roll, Made of...

$29.95

Nora's Nursery Pail Liner for Cloth Diapers - Reusable and Washable - Fi...

$24.95

Nora's Nursery Baby Cloth Pocket Diapers Inserts 10 Pack

$32.95

mushie Baby Hooded Towel | Organic Cotton (Pearl)

$29.99

ATTITUDE Baby Lotion, EWG Verified Moisturizer, Dermatologically Tested ...

$16.99

mushie Baby Hooded Towel | Organic Cotton (Blush)

$29.99

Motherlove Baby & All Soap (32 oz) Gentle Foaming All-Purpose Castile So...

$24.99

haakaa Training Toothbrush Set Oral Care Kit, Soft Silicone Toothbrush f...

$25.99

mushie Baby Bath Cradle Cap Brush | Soft Silicone Bristles for Dry Skin,...

$9.99

haakaa Silicone Shampoo Brush - Cradle Cap Brush Comb - Baby Hair Scrubb...

$9.99

Canopy Baby Bath Tub Filter – Gentler Water Filtration for Delicate Skin...

$89.00

Purrfectzone Bidet Sprayer for Toilet, Handheld Sprayer Kit, Cloth Diape...

$29.99

High Contrast Cards

$22.00

Stella Marie Decade Rosary Puzzle

$19.99

Little Flower | Chews Life Rosary

$38.00

Peek-a-boo Saints Catholic Board Book - Etsy UK

$16.00

The Play Gym

$150.00

Holy Spirit Tower - Wooden Ring Stacker, Catholic Toy, Educational Toy, ...

$25.00

Handmade Mamaroo Balls Replacement Toy Balls for Mamaroo 4moms swing Rem...

$37.90

Haakaa Silicone Clover Teether - Food Grade Silicone Teething Toys for B...

$9.99

Baby's 1st Catholic Book-Contrast

$10.00

The Perfect Baby Gift - Pink

  Must Have

Braun ThermoScan 7 Digital Ear Thermometer for Adults, Babies & Infants,...

$74.99

Haakaa Penguin Nasal Aspirator for Baby – Blocked Nose Relief: Works by ...

$13.99

haakaa Baby Nail Care Electric Baby Nail File Kit with LED Light, Baby N...

$18.99

Motherlove Bump to Baby Box—Baby Shower Gift for Expecting Moms from Mat...

$79.99

mushie Nursing Cover (Blush) | 100% Breathable Organic Cotton | Breastfe...

$19.99

Boppy Nursing Pillow Cover, Organic Green Leaves, Single Cover, Easy-On ...

$24.99

haakaa Silicone Breast Milk Storage Bag 9 oz- Reusable Milk Collector Fr...

$32.59

Haakaa Silicone Colostrum Collectors Set with Clear PP Storage Case 4 ml...

$22.99

Haakaa Silicone Breastmilk Storage Bags Combo 9oz (5 Count)+ 4.4oz (5 Co...

$62.95

Pink Marian Silicone Grace Placemat

$7.49

Silicone Baby Bib - Mother Teresa | Saintly Gift

$30.00

ATTITUDE Baby Bottle & Dish Soap, EWG Verified Bottle Cleaner, Fragrance...

$11.86

Forage Feeder

$18.99

Extra Feeder Tops

$6.50

Ice Cube Tray

$19.99

FRIGG Baby's First Pacifier​ - Moonlight Sailing 4-Pack | Made in Denmar...

$19.99

Boon Nursh Reusable Silicone Pouch Baby Bottles - Slow Flow Nipple - Sil...

$19.99

Babymoov Moov & Feed Portable Cordless Bottle Warmer – Instant Heat for ...

$84.99

Baby Bottle Warmer, Grownsy 10-in-1 Fast Bottle Warmer Accurate Temp Con...

$55.49

Lifefactory 8-Ounce Wide Neck Glass Baby Bottle with Protective Silicone...

$24.99

Baby High Chair, 7 in 1 Convertible High Chairs for Babies and Toddlers,...

$139.99

mushie Baby Bath Rinse Cup | 100% Food Grade Silicone | Shampoo & Body W...

$15.99

Comotomo Baby Bottle Single Pack, Green, 5oz

$12.99

Lifefactory 4-Ounce BPA-Free Glass Baby Bottle with Stage 1 Nipple and P...

$14.99

Lifefactory 8-Ounce Stainless-Steel Vacuum-Insulated Wide-Neck Baby Bott...

$24.99

mushie Muslin Baby Burp Cloths | 100% Organic Cotton, Set of 2 (Blush/Fog)

$24.99

Be A Heart Silicone Baby Bibs, Adjustable Waterproof Bibs, Meal Blessing...

$16.50

FRIGG Natural Rubber Baby Pacifier 6-Pack Blooming Love | Made in Denmar...

$34.99

FRIGG Baby's First Pacifier​ Set | Floral Heart 4-Pack | Made in Denmark...

$19.99

Haakaa Silicone Cleaning Brush Kit – Household Cleaning Brushes for Bott...

$23.99

Haakaa Baby Fruit Food Feeder & Silicone Freezer Nibble Tray Combo - Bre...

$32.90

Hippypotamus Toddler Plates with Suction - 100% Food-Grade Silicone Baby...

$18.98

haakaa Reusable Baby Food Pouches Refillable Baby Squeeze Silicone Yummy...

$48.99

Momcozy Squeeze Station,Baby Food Maker,Pouch Filler for Homemade Baby P...

$35.99

Elk and Friends Stainless Steel Snack Cups | Removable Silicone Food Cat...

$19.99

Elk and Friends Silicone Baby Spoons | Travel Case Included | First Stag...

$12.99

Elk and Friends Stainless Steel Divided Plates with Silicone Sleeve for ...

$33.99

Elk and Friends Kids 6.7” Porcelain Divided Plates with Silicone Suction...

$38.99

Blessed Sacrament Saint Bracelet | Mustard

$17.00

Immaculate Heart of Mary Saint Bracelet | | Light Blue

$17.00

Bib 7 Pack - Hibiscus

$38.00

Noah | Silicone Pacifier Clip

$24.00

Our Lady Star of the Sea Swimsuit: UPF 50+ Catholic Swim

$10.00

Adoration Lovey: Bamboo Baby Blanket, Catholic Gift

$25.50

Burp Cloth 4 Pack - Palaka Zinnia Multi

  Must Have

Plumeria Burp Cloth

Diaper Changing Pad - Lilac Vintage Tiare

  Must Have

Millie Moon Sensitive Wipes - 648ct

  Must Have

Millie Moon Luxury Disposable Diapers - Size 2 - 96ct

  Must Have

Millie Moon Luxury Disposable Diapers - Size 1 - 108ct

  Must Have

Chi-rho Christian Beaded Raindrops - Montessori Wooden Rainmaker - Etsy ...

Holy Family Hearts Minky Blanket for Comfort and Love

Yoofoss Waterproof Crib Mattress Protector 2 Pack, Quilted Crib Mattress...

Pasta for Baby High Contrast Cards Sensory Toy Learning Activity Large B...

Collapsible Baby Bathtub - Large Baby Bath Tub with Thermometer & Cushio...

mushie Baby Diaper Caddy | Newborn Essentials Organizer for Diaper Chang...

Inglesina Fast Table Chair, Dark Green - Portable Baby High Chair - for ...

Mecc ecoh Baby Bassinet Mattress, 100% Breathable Cover, Water-Resistant...

Momcozy Breathable Mesh Baby Carrier, Ergonomic and Lightweight Infant C...

mushie Muslin Organic Cotton Washcloths 5-Pack (Retro Flowers Combo) | S...

Storkcraft 6-Inch Water-Resistant Grow-with-Me Crib & Toddler Mattress —...

mushie Extra Soft Muslin Fitted Crib Sheet 2-Pack | 192 Thread Count | 2...

Catholic Baby Swaddle Muslin Blanket | Rosary Dots

Baby Swaddle - Creme Retro Orchid

Boppy Nursing Pillow - Ergonomic Bottle & Breastfeeding Pillow with High...

Nora's Nursery Reusable Swim Diapers and Wet Bag - One Size Fully Adjust...

Pro Goleem Baby Bassinet Mattress Pad 32"x18" Rectangle, Waterproof Soft...

Poppylist Shop Gift Card

Millie Moon Luxury Disposable Diapers - Newborn - 96ct

  Must Have

Jool Baby Waterproof Baby Changing Pad - Easy to Clean, Lightweight & Po...

Motherlove Baby & All Soap (Variety Pack, 3.4oz) Travel Size Gentle Foam...

Hooku Silicone Teethers for Babies 6-12 Months, Teething Toys for Babies...

Millie Moon Luxury Disposable Diapers - Size 2 - 31ct

  Must Have

haakaa Baby Hair Brush and Comb Set for Newborns & Toddlers - Natural So...

Baby Brezza Sterilizer Dryer Advanced - White

Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail, Odor Locking, No Special Bag Required, Award-Win...

Storkcraft Timeless Reclining Glider (Ivory) -USB Charging Port, 360-Deg...

Storkcraft Sicily 3-in-1 Convertible Crib with Toddler Rail Included – G...