14-Meal Assortment Starter Kit

$99.00

  Poppylist Pick

Zippered Footie in Giraffe

$39.00

Zippered Footie in The Very Hungry Caterpillar™ and Friends

$39.00

Zippered Footie in Golf

$39.00

white serene safari modal magnetic parent favorite footie

$40.00

Frida Baby 4-in-1 Grow-with-Me Baby Bathtub, Baby Tub for Newborns to To...

Dreft Stage 1 Newborn Baby Laundry Detergent Liquid, HE Compatible, 114 ...

Frida Baby Ultimate Baby Kit | Baby Essentials Gift Set Includes Wellnes...

  Must Have

Poppylist Shop Gift Card

Ninni Pacifier Blueberry 1 Pack

Bright Starts Stay Cool Teethers, Water-Filled & Chillable, BPA Free Tee...

Note from Erin & Jonathan : "Teething - won't need for a few months, but the second it's needed, will be thankful to have!"

Hatch Grow Smart Changing Pad and Scale (White)

  Must Have

Breathable, Organic Cotton Sheets (2-pack) | Newton Baby

Giraffe Receiving Blanket

Note from Erin & Jonathan : "Coordinates with his nursery theme!"

HIYAGON Baby Laundry Basket Animal Hamper Rectangular Storage Box for Or...

Luna Lullaby Nursing Pillow - Blue Dot

  Must Have

EveryStep™ Slim 6-in-1 Highchair | Graco Baby

Travel Crib & Play Yard Sheets | Newton Baby

3-in-1 Portable Baby Bouncer & Rocker Chair for Newborn to Toddler - 4 A...

Foldable Baby Playpen 50"×50", Out-of-The-Box Ready Playpen for Babies a...

Note from Erin & Jonathan : "Once baby is mobile, this can be a lifesaver!"

Fisher-Price Portable Bassinet On-The-Go Baby Dome, Travel Play Space wi...

Note from Erin & Jonathan : "Easy, safe place to put baby that's easy to travel with"

fairway fetch modal magnetic polo romper

Lily Miles Baby Diaper Caddy - Large Organizer Tote Bag for Newborn esse...

DESITIN Maximum Strength Original Diaper Rash Paste 3-Piece Variety Size...

Note from Erin & Jonathan : "Great for multiple diaper stations plus on the go!"

WaterWipes Plastic-Free Soothing Clean 99% Water Based Botanical Baby Wi...

  Must Have

Note from Erin & Jonathan : "Best for sensitive skin"

Frida Baby 4-in-1 Grow-with-Me Baby Bathtub, Baby Tub for Newborns to To...

Burt's Bees Baby Shampoo and Body Wash, Tear Free Soap, 98% Natural Orig...

TUBBY TODD Baby Bundle Newborn Skin Care Set - Hypoallergenic Hair + Bod...

Bath Kneeler and Elbow Rest Pad, 1.75 inch Extra Thick Baby Bath Kneelin...

Soft Bamboo Baby Washcloths Set For Newborn

Note from Erin & Jonathan : "Great for sensitive skin"

Dinosaur Hooded Towel | Buddy

Note from Erin & Jonathan : "Will fit through toddler years while baby will outgrow others in first year"

Frida Baby Control The Flow Bathtub Sprayer Attachment for Baby Bathtub,...

Baby Einstein 4-in-1 Kickin' Tunes Music and Language Play Gym and Piano...

Baby's Sensory Toys Gift Box

Bright Starts Hug-a-bye, Baby Elephant, jouet musical et animal en peluc...

Tiny Love Meadow Days Baby Mobile for Crib, Newborn Baby Toys, Portable ...

Lansinoh Breast Therapy Packs, Hot and Cold Breast-Pads with 2 Soft Cove...

Kindred Bravely Organic Reusable Nursing Pads, Washable, for Breastfeedi...

Lansinoh Breastmilk Storage Bags, 150 Count, Baby Essentials, Fast Freez...

Motherlove Nipple Cream (2 oz) Organic Lanolin-Free Nipple Cream for Bre...

Spectra - S1 Plus Electric Breast Milk Pump with Tote Bag, Breast Milk B...

  Must Have

Milkies Milk-Saver Breast Milk Collector Storage

TUCKS Medicated Cooling Pads, 100 Count – Pads with Witch Hazel, Cleanse...

Frida Mom Upside Down Peri Bottle for Postpartum Care, Portable Bidet Pe...

Aveeno Skin Relief Fragrance-Free Moisturizing Lotion for Sensitive Skin...

Babylist Bottle Box (5 Bottles) | Babylist Shop

Note from Erin & Jonathan : "Trial and error - great for trying multiple options"

Burt's Bees Baby Infant Burp Cloths, 100% Organic Cotton Extra Absorbent...

Burt's Bees Baby Infant Pull On Bibs, 100% Organic Cotton Lap Shoulder S...

Baby Brezza Bottle Sterilizer and Dryer Advanced – 33% Faster - Largest ...

Dish Bundle by Dapple Baby Includes Baby Bottle & Dish Liquid by Dapple ...

Tommee Tippee Multiwarm Bottle and Pouch Warmer, White, Warms Baby Feeds...

  Must Have

4moms MamaRoo Multi-Motion Baby Swing, Bluetooth Enabled with 5 Unique M...

Note from Erin & Jonathan : "Good soothing option that allows for free arms!"